How to shop for auto insurance like a pro

Published on November 16, 2026
2 mins reading time
A woman looks at her tablet on the sofa, smiling beamingly.

Shopping for auto insurance isn’t just about price. To properly evaluate quotes, you need to use the right approaches and provide accurate information. Whether you’re buying a new policy or renewing your auto insurance, comparing car insurance quotes is essential to get a clear picture of the car insurance market and make an informed choice.

How to compare auto insurance quotes

Contact insurers directly

This is the most thorough way to compare insurance quotes if you have the time. You get precise answers tailored to your situation. See our tip on how to prepare for an auto insurance quote.

  • Ask to receive quotes in writing, ideally by email.
  • Compare the amounts, types of coverage (including optional coverage and additional coverage) and deductibles.
  • Check whether the prices include taxes.

Go through a broker

A property and casualty insurance broker can compare several insurers for you. It’s a good option if you want guidance.

  • Make sure the broker works with several insurance companies.
  • Ask to see all the quotes obtained, even those that aren’t recommended.
  • Ask questions about coverage (such as liability insurance, theft, vandalism or damage to your vehicle), exclusions and deductibles.

Use an online quote comparison tool

These tools are convenient and fast for getting a first overview. But keep in mind:

  • Results are limited to partner insurers, which doesn’t always reflect the entire market.
  • You’ll only receive a few offers.
  • Coverage can be structured differently from one policy to another, which can make comparisons harder.

Good to know: When you use an online comparison tool, your contact information may be shared with insurers. You could therefore receive follow-up calls.

Pro tip

“Combine approaches: contact a few insurers, use a comparison tool and consult a broker to broaden your options. Don’t rely on price alone. Also compare coverage, deductibles, exclusions and services. That’s where the real difference lies.”

Jean-François CharestVice President, Insurance, CAA-Québec

What to tell your auto insurer (and why your premium may change)

Your auto insurance premium is calculated based on several factors: your address, how the vehicle is used, authorized drivers and more. As soon as one of these changes, you must report it.

Here are the main changes to report:

  • Moving: Risk varies based on the number and type of insurance claims made in your area.
  • Driving outside Quebec: Especially if you drive in the United States.
  • Change in vehicle use: Carpooling, delivery work, etc.
  • Adding or removing a driver: A young driver or another family member.
  • Driving history: Licence suspension for impaired driving, for example.
  • Change in annual mileage: The number of kilometres on your policy must reflect your actual driving habits.
  • Vehicle modifications: High-end audio system, custom rims, mechanical modifications.
  • Installing or removing an anti-theft device.

Why report these changes to your insurer?

These factors affect your risk level and can change your insurance premiums, even with a clean driving record. If your information isn’t up to date, your policy may no longer suit your needs, and a claim could be denied or reduced.

Compare and report changes to choose the best auto insurance

To choose auto insurance that fits your situation, combine several methods and provide accurate information. Make sure you compare equivalent insurance quotes. That way, you’ll avoid unpleasant surprises and better understand what affects your premium.

Also read our tips on how to save on your auto insurance premium.

See how our Auto and Vehicle Insurance can meet all your needs!

To ask your questions:
1-844-446-3636